Popular CD Rippers/MP3 Encoders Comparison Table

Title Mp3 to Mp3
Conversions
Encoding
Engine
Normal-
ization
Comp-
ression
Trim Silence Shareware/Demo
Limitations
Personal Observations Retail Price
Audio Catalyst (Xing)
v2.1
No XingMP3 Yes No Yes Rips random CD tracks, Encode only 128k MP3, Cannot load Wav files. Uncanny likeness to AudioGrabber. A predecessor? $29.99
AudioGrabber
v1.81
No Frnhfr(56k)
External
Yes Yes Yes Randomly rips only half of a CDs Tracks. Brighter highs at 56k than other Fraunhofer encoders. $20
Cool Edit 2000
v1.1
Yes Frnhfr Yes Yes Yes 30 minutes per session, No save function. Lots of great editing features. Manual, analog CD ripping is slow & cumbersome. $69
EZ CD-DA Extractor
v4.6.1
Yes Frnhfr(56k)
Lame
Others
Yes No No Limited to 20 uses. Brighter highs at 56k than other Fraunhofer encoders. $24.95
Goldwave
v4.25
Yes External Yes Yes Yes Shareware notices. Pending... $35-$40
MusicMatch
v7.0
Yes Frnhfr No No Yes Slower Encoding & fewer misc utils. Nice library cataloging system. $19.99
MP3 Gain
v1.0.3
No N/A Yes No No None Intelligent Normalization. Best one I've found. No loss in audio quality. Free
MP3 Trim
v1.78
No N/A Yes No Yes 2.5meg filesize limitation, no batch processing. Nice, very fast normalizer with no audio quality loss. But it's over priced. $80


Misc MP3 Tools

Title Function Shareware/Demo
Limitations
Personal Observations Retail Price
EncSpot MP3 Analyzer Fully functional shareware version. Pro version has nice cache feature Reports many properties of MP3's, but I use mostly the reports on encoding rate, Sync Errors, and bad last files. $19.99
mp3DirectCut MP3 Editor None Takes a little time to become familiar with the interface, but a nice little "quickie" MP3 editor. Free
TagScanner MP3 Tag Editor/File ReNamer None Again, takes a little time to become familiar with the interface, but a nice little "quickie" utility. Free